Insurance or Private Pay?

Pink piggy bank with adhesive bandages on its side, sitting on a wooden surface against a dark background.

What are the pros of using insurance for therapy?

Depending on your plan, your out-of-pocket expenses may be lower. Insurance can help alleviate some of the cost of therapy. This is an important consideration, especially in today’s economy.

Your diagnosis and treatment become part of your medical record. For some this may be very helpful, especially when securing additional services for a mental health disorder.

What are the pros of paying privately for counseling?

Greater Privacy. More Freedom. Care Centered on You. Choosing private-pay counseling offers an opportunity to approach therapy with greater privacy, flexibility, and personal choice. Some benefits of private pay include:

  • Limitations and Restrictions. Insurance companies use in-house auditors to determine eligible diagnosis, approve ongoing treatment, determine number of covered sessions, etc.

  • Greater Privacy and Confidentiality.

    • Private-pay eliminates the need to share sensitive diagnostic and treatment information with a third party such as your insurance providers.

    • Privacy may be of growing importance with AI entering the therapy space (i.e. listening to / recording therapy sessions to automatically generate a transcript and draft clinical notes). And the emerging trend of biometric data collection may be on the horizons.

    Your mental health information deserves thoughtful protection. Think of all the personal information that you are likely to or have shared with a therapist. Whether you choose to use insurance or not for counseling, privacy may be something you want to discuss with your provider at the onset of services.

  • A diagnosis is required for coverage.

    • Insurance requires a mental health diagnosis to cover services. Not every reason for seeking counseling fits neatly into a diagnostic category. Grief, life transitions, relationship challenges, spiritual exploration, identity shifts, and personal growth are meaningful reasons to seek support, whether or not a mental health diagnosis is present.

    • Authorization of coverage and justification for services is dependent upon having a mental health diagnosis - this includes couple and family therapy. When using insurance for couple or family therapy, one person will need to be identified as “the client”. The identified client’s diagnosis is used to justify couple or family therapy.

  • An Individualized, Holistic Approach. Healing is not always linear, and meaningful change involves more than symptom reduction. Private-pay counseling offers greater flexibility to integrate evidence-based psychotherapy with approaches that honor the interconnectedness of mind, body, emotions, and personal beliefs. Choosing private-pay counseling is ultimately about creating space for therapy that honors the whole person rather than a diagnosis or a set of symptoms. My commitment is to provide compassionate, individualized care that respects your privacy, supports your autonomy, and recognizes that healing, self-discovery, and personal growth are deeply personal experiences.

A few things to consider about mental health diagnoses...

Benefits of Diagnosis

  • If you meet criteria for a mental health diagnosis, you may have greater access to treatment and support.

  • A diagnosis can offer some clarity about symptoms. Having a label/name for your experiences can reduce stress.

  • It provides medical professionals with a common language and framework for treatment.

  • It can be helpful for those seeking educational or vocational assistance.

Concerns About Diagnosing

  • Over-Medicalization of the Human Experience.

    • When we adopt a purely medical model for mental health it can lead to an over-simplification of complex challenges.

    • Diagnosis does not offer insight about the root cause(s). And, the impact of societal and familial systems is often minimized which contributes to stigmatization of the individual.

    • Over-Diagnosis and Over-Treatment. The term “disease mongering” has been used by some to convey a growing frustration about pathologizing typical life experiences. The U.S. CDC, as well as the Canadian government, have acknowledged a significant increase in children diagnosed with mental disorders and placed on medication (a 41% increase over the last decade), deepening concerns about labeling some child behaviors as pathological. (https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC3665855/) .

  • Ethical Considerations. While the DSM (Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders) is subject to extensive review and input, a couple concerns persist.

    • Some mental health professionals see the nondisclosure of financial conflicts-of-interest between review committee members and the pharmaceutical industry as problematic (Davis, et al, 2023). Recent criticism centers on the broadening and marketing of diagnostic categories as contributing to a greatly expanded patient population and the over-prescription of medication.

    • Another growing concern is that mental health, when conceptualized through a “Western or Eurocentric” lens, discounts (or worse pathologizes) cultural differences and enables systems of oppression (Mullan, 2023).

  • Diagnostic Variability. Diagnoses can vary greatly from one therapist to another. Unlike medical doctors, there are no blood tests or scans for diagnosing mental illness. Diagnosis depends on self-reports, observation, interviews, and rating scales. The human experience does not fit neatly into prescribed categories and symptoms can overlap with multiple diagnoses. At times, it can feel like we are trying to fit a uniquely shaped set of experiences into a standard square hole. Lastly, trends in diagnosis (and treatment) vary and are influenced by popularity, education, and biases within the field.

References / Further Reading

  • Boyd, E. & Bero, L. (2000). Assessing faculty financial relationships with industry. JAMA, 284, 2209–2214.

  • Davis, L., Diianni, A., Drumheller, S., et al. (2023). Undisclosed financial conflicts of interest in DSM-5-TR: cross sectional analysis. BMJ, 384, e076902.

  • Cosgrove L, D'Ambrozio G, Herrawi F, Freeman M and Shaughnessy A (2023) Why psychiatry needs an honest dose of gentle medicine. Front. Psychiatry 14:1167910. doi: 10.3389/fpsyt.2023.1167910\
    Melander, H., Ahlqvist-Rastad, I., Meijer, G., et al. (2003). Evidence b(i)ased medicine – selective reporting from studies sponsored by the pharmaceutical industry. BMJ, 326, 1171–1173.

  • Mullan, J. (2023). Decolonizing therapy: oppression, historical trauma, and politicizing your practice. W. W. Norton